Generator Control Mode: Isochronous vs Droop Control Comparison

Electric power systems use generators to produce electricity, which is then transmitted and distributed to end-users. In order to maintain the stability and reliability of the power system, it is necessary to control the output of these generators using a specific generator control mode. Two common methods for controlling the output of generators are isochronous and droop control modes.

Isochronous GeneratorControl Mode

In an isochronous generator control modes, the generator output is controlled to maintain a constant frequency, typically 50 Hz or 60 Hz. This is done by adjusting the speed of the generator in response to changes in the load demand. The speed governor of the generator is designed to respond quickly to changes in the load demand, ensuring that the frequency remains constant.

For example, imagine a power system with two generators, A and B, each with an isochronous control mode. If the load demand increases, the frequency of the power system will start to drop. Both generators will increase their output to compensate for the increased demand and maintain a constant frequency. If one generator is unable to increase its output for some reason, such as a mechanical failure, the other generator will compensate and increase its output further to maintain a constant frequency.

Droop Control Mode

In a droop control mode, the generator output is controlled to maintain a constant voltage, but the frequency can vary with the load demand. The output of the generator is reduced as the load demand increases, causing the frequency of the power system to drop. This is known as droop, hence the name droop control mode.

For example, imagine a power system with two generators, A and B, each with a droop control mode. If the load demand increases, the frequency of the power system will start to drop. The output of both generators will decrease due to droop, but the generator with the larger droop setting will decrease its output more, and hence will contribute less to the total load demand. The other generator will pick up the slack and increase its output to compensate for the increased demand.

Comparison of Isochronous and Droop Control

The main difference between isochronous and droop control modes is the way they respond to changes in the load demand. In an isochronous control mode, the generator output is adjusted to maintain a constant frequency, while in a droop control mode, the generator output is adjusted to maintain a constant voltage, with frequency allowed to vary. Isochronous control mode is generally used in systems where maintaining a constant frequency is critical, such as in some industrial and military applications. Droop control mode is more commonly used in power systems with multiple generators, where maintaining a constant frequency is less critical.

Advantages and disadvantages of Droop and Isochronous modes.

Here are some more detailed advantages and disadvantages of each mode, as well as situations in which each mode is typically used:

Advantages of Isochronous Control Mode:

• Maintains a constant frequency, which is important for some industrial and military applications.
• Fast response to load changes, as the speed governor can adjust the output quickly.

Lear more about specific power generators like in hydro power plants, read the article on Hydroelectric Power Plants.

Disadvantages of Isochronous Generator Control Modes:

• Requires precise speed control of the generator, which can be challenging to achieve.
• Can lead to instability in the power system if one generator is unable to increase its output, leading to overloading of other generators.

When is Isochronous Generator Control Mode used?

• In applications where maintaining a constant frequency is critical, such as in some industrial and military applications.
• In power systems with a single generator, where maintaining a constant frequency is important.

Advantages of Droop Control Mode:

• Provides a stable and predictable response to load changes, as the output is reduced as the load increases.
• Allows for multiple generators to share the load, which can improve the reliability of the power system.

Disadvantages of Droop Control Mode:

• The frequency of the power system can vary with changes in load demand, which may be unacceptable for some applications.
• Response to load changes can be slower than with isochronous control mode, as the droop setting limits the amount that the output can change.

When is Droop Control Mode used?

• In power systems with multiple generators, where sharing the load is important for reliability.
• In systems where maintaining a constant voltage is critical, but maintaining a constant frequency is less important.

Choosing between Isochronous and Droop Control

In summary, the choice between isochronous and droop control modes depends on the specific requirements of the power system. Isochronous control mode is generally used in applications where maintaining a constant frequency is critical, while droop control mode is more commonly used in power systems with multiple generators where sharing the load is important for reliability.

Conclusion

In conclusion, isochronous and droop control modes are two common methods for controlling the output of generators in electric power systems. While both methods have their advantages and disadvantages, the choice between them depends on the specific requirements of the power system.